Contrasting Tenses
2. Signal words
2.1. Who needs correct tenses?!
Choosing the wrong tense might lead to some misunderstandings. Look at the following video:
He says … |
He should have said … |
I go to school in Berlin Meaning: He is still a student. |
I went to school (past simple) Meaning: He completed his studies and he no longer studies. |
I live in Milano, I live in Sri Lanka Meaning: He lives in 2 different places at the same time! |
I lived in Milano, I lived in Sri Lanka (past simple) Meaning: He spent time in these two places and it is over now. |
But I always live here Meaning: He lives in France. |
I am still living here. |
I have burger Meaning: He does not need to order as he has a burger. |
I will have a burger (future) Meaning: |
I have four girlfriends Meaning: He dates 4 women. He is polygamous! |
I have had four girlfriends (present perfect) Meaning: He dated 4 women in the past -> valeur de bilan |
I love all my girlfriends Meaning: He dates and loves 4 women! |
I have loved all my girlfriends (present perfect) Meaning: He loved each of them at the time he dated them -> valeur de bilan |
I never date Indian women* Meaning: This is racist : he does not date women who are Indian! |
I have never dated Indian women (present perfect) Meaning: He has never had an indian girlfriend but why not date one -> valeur de bilan |
⇒ The boy uses present simple in all his sentences. Present simple is used for established facts and things in general and also for habitual activities or routines. |
* Keep in mind that in more complex structures it is important to look at the action in a sentence rather than a signal word.
Never/always…
+ simple present -> a habit or a routine (=> a present tense in French)
+ present perfect -> assessment (=> a past tense in French)
For + duration (e.g. for 4 years)
+ past simple -> pendant (4 ans)
+ present perfect -> depuis (4 ans)